TaxWatch comments on new OECD proposals to tax multinationals

by | Oct 10, 2019

The OECD has published new proposals which seek to deal with the problem of profit shifting by multinational companies.

The proposals set out principles on how large multinational companies should be taxed in the future. At the core of the proposals is a new approach to how the profit of companies should be allocated to different countries in which they operate.

These proposals are a starting point. There will now be a period of negotiation with the OECD seeking to get agreement early next year.

As highlighted in research by TaxWatch, the current system allows multinational companies to easily shift profit out of the countries which they operate and into tax havens where no real economic activities take place.

Our research found that just five companies dodged £1bn a year in UK corporation tax through profit shifting between 2012-2017.

The proposals from the OECD would redistribute just a fraction of that profit back to the UK.

Commenting, TaxWatch director George Turner said:

“The proposals from the OECD move away from the absurd system where a multinational company is treated as if it is a network of independently trading companies. That is a good thing.

“However, the proposals set out yesterday are limited in scope and analysis has shown that they will only redistribute a small amount of the profit multinationals currently shift offshore.

“The fact of the matter is that the UK government could immediately tackle the issue of profit shifting by tech companies if it wanted to. All it needs to do is to change existing legislation which exempts tax havens like Ireland, Switzerland and the Bahamas from income tax on royalties. TaxWatch has estimated that such a move would allow the UK to raise an extra £8bn in taxes a year.

“With consultation on the plans now open, there is still a lot to play for and it is important that civil society and other groups engage with the process in order make the argument for a system that ensures that governments see a real benefit from the profits made by multinationals in their jurisdiction.”

Related stories

Unveiling the latest Box office smash hit: Creative industry tax relief reach record highs

Unveiling the latest Box office smash hit: Creative industry tax relief reach record highs

Record levels of tax relief claimed by the creative industries sector in 2023. The reliefs are now dominated by fewer, extremely large, claims for film and ‘high-end’ TV programmes. TaxWatch questions whether these reliefs offer good value for money given the profitability of expensive productions in light of changes to the Audio Visual Expenditure Credit.

The SME R&D tax relief scheme: lessons in how not to implement a tax relief

The SME R&D tax relief scheme: lessons in how not to implement a tax relief

Once again, the National Audit Office qualified HMRC’s accounts due to a “material level of error and fraud in Corporation Tax research and development reliefs”. Whilst the good news is that the estimated error rate within the relief is coming down it remains unacceptably high. It has taken years for HMRC to admit there were problems, despite plenty of warnings, and action has been too slow to avoid the situation getting totally out of hand.

Press contacts

For all media enquiries about TaxWatch or to be added to our media email list, please contact:

Claire Aston, TaxWatch Director

claire@taxwatchuk.org

+44 7494 922661


Newsletter

Enter your email address to subscribe to our newsletter.

Please wait...

Thank you - please click on the link in the email we've just sent to confirm your subscription.